The term presumption of regularity reflects a principle within the judicial system that leads judges to default to assuming criminal and civil cases and evidence and filings related to them are being brought to the court in good faith by the government professionals involved and do not require or merit explicit validation before being incorporated into deliberations. Under this principle, when officials within the government at the federal, state or local level appear in court or supply information to courts, that information is essential accepted without question. When those officials are all performing their work in accordance with high ethical standards, this assumption saves the court and those officials significant time, making the entire process more efficient in protecting the larger public.
Over the first two years of the second Trump mis-Administration, a growing number of federal judges handling prosecutions, lawsuits and filings by Trump DOJ officials have not only rejected those efforts in record numbers due to their laughable premises and supporting "evidence", those judges began explicitly noting in their rulings that they reached a point where they were no longer willing to provide the DOJ the presumption of regularity. ProPublica published a story in July 2026 noting this abysmal DOJ track record and these accompanying written opinions by the judges regarding the presumption of regularity, bringing this concept into wider discussion.
The ProPublica story title pretty much says it all.
Federal Judges Chastise Trump’s Justice Department for “Unlawful,” “Unethical” and “Unseemly” ConductUnlawful. Unethical. Unseemly. That pretty much nails it, doesn't it?
America just concluded the 2026 mid-term election that changed control of both houses of Congress from Republican to Democratic and changed numerous Governor seats and statewide offices from Republican to Democratic as well. That means some measure of balance can be restored to stop these abuses and allow a return to presumptive regularity, right?
Absolutely wrong.
There is no shortage of examples refuting any such wishful thinking, even if the search is limited to events that have captured public attention AFTER the midterm election. Events such as:
- Allegations Nvidia knowingly circumvented export restrictions on its advanced GPU gear, allowing billions of dollars worth of gear to EITHER a) physically wind up within China for use in its commercial and military applications OR b) be deployed in another country by a firm operated as a shell company to physically operate the hardware OUTSIDE China while actually leasing ACCESS to that compute power TO Chinese firms used by the Chinese government.
- Rumors of multiple affairs by the Nvidia CEO being pushed to the press from within the US State Department as part of Marco Rubio's goal of enforcing rigid restrictions on technology exports to China as part of a larger anti-China strategy.
- Rumors of multiple affairs by the Nvidia CEO being pushed to the press from within US AI technology companies (Anthropic and OpenAI, specifically) in the hopes of triggering the ouster of a key technology executive who SUPPORTS the development of open-source AI technologies and weighting systems which are OPPOSED by firms such as Anthropic and OpenAI who prefer closed-source proprietary systems.
- The President of the United States publicly opining on matters related to the possible change of control at Nvidia before it happened, suggested replacements (Tim Cook?) after Huang's resignation and further speculation on Huang's next career steps after Nvidia appointed a replacement.
- Clear evidence that earlier attempts in 2025 and early 2026 to halt additional Nvidia gear shipments that were likely violating export restrictions were thwarted by the direct involvement of Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick.
- Dozens of technology execs and tens of thousands of technology company employees in and out of Nvidia signing a public petition urging the Nvidia board to rehire said former CEO, despite questions about the equipment sales and his ethical and managerial failings regarding the affairs, at least one of which he has publicly acknowledged.
- Cabinet secretaries appearing in live TV press conferences fighting for their personal agendas against each other and contradicting each other regarding a firm and industry that is both legitimately valuable to the United States economically and strategically but is ALSO a key enabler of a financial bubble triggered by a wider pattern of corruption fostered by the Trump Administration.
But, but, but, but...
Congress just changed hands, both the House and Senate will have Democratic majorities that can convene hearings and get to the bottom of all of this industrial scale skullduggery, right?
Again, absolutely wrong.
Applicable committees in the House and Senate can call all the witnesses they want on any topic they desire but the White House is occupied by a man who has already demonstrated he is willing to pardon any person for any action if it protects his personal financial / legal interests. Trump himself has previously threatened to "pardon anyone who walked within two hundred feet of the Oval Office" whenever the prospect of subpoenas of Trump administration officials and friends has been raised. And remember that Congress doesn't operate its own police force or marshal service to physically compel subpoenaed witnesses to appear. Any charge of criminal contempt must be referred to the DOJ which has already demonstrated it is led by those directing the very crimes requiring investigation. A weaker charge of "inherent contempt" can allow the Sergeant at Arms of the House or Senate to physically take a party in custody. This power hasn't been used since 1934 and presents a key limitation. The Sergeant at Arms for the House or Senate is a single PERSON, not an organization, and has no resources to track down dozens of Presidentially protected subpoena targets. The process simply cannot work in the face of wholesale corruption by the Executive Branch and DOJ.
Well if Trump pardons them, that eliminates any Fifth Amendment protections for witnesses, they'd have to testify about anything asked and we could still get to the bottom of these matters, right? Well, they would certainly have to testify but a pardon doesn't suddenly guarantee the witness will speak the truth thereafter. And if such a person is subpoenaed, receives a pardon, testifies, then lies in their compelled testimony, then what? They can be found in contempt of Congress but, again, that's a FEDERAL CRIME which is again subject to Presidential pardon and the snake eats its tail.
And suppose if this subpoena / plead fifth / pardon/ testify cycle occurs and years of hearings eventually document what actually happened in all its criminal glory. What has been accomplished if all of the criminals identified have scored Presidential pardons? The United States is already in its post-shame era. Mere exposure of onerous criminal acts no longer provides sufficient incentives to stop bad behavior on the part of uber-rich oligarchs and IQ-impaired quislings willing to do their bidding in elected office or appointed positions within the government. Hearings that yield no actual tangible PUNISHMENT for blatant criminal acts with national / global impacts and dozens or hundreds of PARDONED criminals simply serve as a how-to seminar for more corruption.
After considering
- the ethical and moral black hole that is the mind of Donald Trump
- a new "presumptive immunity" power fabricated out of whole cloth by the US Supreme Court in 2024 that extended additional protections around "outer perimeter" functions of the Presidency
- the demonstrated corruption and criminal incompetence of every Trump Cabinet Secretary
- a larger Republican Party that has already demonstrated it has reverted to a mode of thwarting any Democratic legislative initiative or oversight effort
it is clear that virtually every Constitutional check and balance intended by the founders to correct abuses of a corrupt Executive Branch are still fundamentally crippled as long as remaining Republicans refuse to contribute to a two-thirds vote on impeachments. Not just an impeachment of Trump, but virtually every Cabinet Secretary. Short of that, Trump could
- veto every bill passed by a Democratic Congress out of sheer spite
- interfere with every Congressional investigation by directing friendly witnesses to reject subpoenas then pardoning contempt charges
- and still unleash havoc across the globe militarily and financially
The only power Democrats truly hold at this point is the power to block any new Executive branch appointment that requires the advice and consent of the Senate and judicial appointments. And even that power is of dubious value because leaving crucial positions in regulatory and judicial functions unfilled is a core part of the Trump strategy of impairing the government's ability to enforce the law while his crime spree continues.
As a final note, it isn't just a fetid Republican Party facing blame for preserving this moral and ethical rot at the core of the United States. The circumstances of Jensen Huang's exit from Nvidia and the petition to "re-instate" him -- as if corporate leadership selections should be driven by public opinion polls, Kalshi "futures" predictions and Presidential whims -- speaks volumes about the priorities of the financial / investment sphere.
Huang likely contributed to violations of export laws involving equipment tagged as national security related. Huang violated internal management rules regarding sexual relationships with subordinates. Huang may yet be tied to charges of financial manipulations and false financial reporting when the full nature of his circular financing deals lending money in exchange for hardware are fully researched. Yet dozens of technology execs and thousands of technology serfs are willing to see him re-instated to protect their investment in Nvidia stock?
Nothing, I repeat NOTHING, is going to be "regular" about the coming months.
WTH